Menu Expand

Framing Spaces in Motion

Tracing Visualizations of Earthquakes into Twentieth-Century San Francisco

Leikam, Susanne

American Studies – A Monograph Series, Bd. 255

2015

Zusätzliche Informationen

Bibliografische Daten

Abstract

‘Framing Spaces in Motion’ explores how communities come to terms with earthquakes as well as the risk of their recurrences and how these moments of physical and ideological rupture emerge as sites of negotiation for preexisting cultural, political, and economic conflicts. From an in-depth examination of the early modern European textual and visual repertoires of making sense of earthquakes, ‘Framing Spaces in Motion’ traces the development of earthquake discourses and framing patterns into the nineteenth-century United States. A profound discussion of the historical protocols of disaster discourses in the San Francisco Bay Area paves the ground for an extensive analysis of the earthquake framings of one of the most prolifically visualized events at the turn of the century, the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake and Fire. ‘Framing Spaces in Motion’ is the first comprehensive study to investigate the rhetorical and pictorial conventions of framing earthquakes from a transnational perspective and also one of the first to devote ample attention to the visual culture of natural disasters by assessing earthquake pictures in their interpictorial relationships, (in)visibilities, and strategic manipulations. In addition to its grounding in Transnational American Studies, the analysis is located at the intersection of visual culture studies, disaster studies, ecocriticism, and memory studies.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Zwischenüberschrift Seite Aktion Preis
Contents VII
Acknowledgements i
Prologue: How the Pictures Became the Frames 1
1. Introduction:‘ Framing Spaces in Motion’ 5
2. Introducing the Conceptual Scaffolding 11
2.1 Emplacing ‘Framing Spaces in Motion’ in American Studies 11
2.2 ‘Nature’ and ‘Disasters’ in Their (Inter-)Disciplinary Contexts 13
2.3 Earthquake Frames 27
2.4 The Pictorial Interplay in Earthquake Pictures 32
3. On the Pictorial Repertoire of Earthquake Illustrations 47
3.1 European Conventions of ‘Framing Spaces in Motion’ 47
3.2 American Practices and Traditions of Depicting Earthquakes 83
4. Framing San Francisco’s Early Firesand Earthquakes 127
4.1 The Risings of the Phoenix: The Six Great Conflagrations 127
4.2 Nineteenth-Century Tremors in San Francisco 157
5. The 1906 San Francisco Earthquake and Fire 205
5.1 ‘The day of the end of the world’: April 18, 1906 205
5.2 The Visual Culture of the 1906 San Francisco Calamity 215
5.3 The Framings of the 1906 Disaster in and beyond Picture Frames 234
5.4 Re-Framing the Earthquake and Fire Pictures of 1906 276
Fig. 36: “Looking West” (1906 227
Fig. 37: “View of Nob Hill” (1906 227
Fig. 38: “Looking Northwest” (1906 227
Fig. 39: Map from “San Francisco: The Imperishable” (1906 229
Fig. 40: Map from San Francisco and Vicinity (1906 229
Fig. 41: Chas Ehrer, Custom-Made Postcard (1906 232
Fig. 42: Allegorical Drawing of the Rising Phoenix (1906 236
Fig. 43: “Effect of the Earthquake” (1906 241
Fig. 44: “Result of Earthquake” (1906 241
Fig. 45: Pre-Fire Panorama of San Francisco (1906 246
Fig. 46: Post-Fire Panorama of San Francisco (1906 246
Fig. 47: Advertisement for “Pompeii in America” (ca. 1906 249
Fig. 48: Anna Biggs, Drawing of the Ruined City Hall (1906 251
Fig. 49: Louis J. Stellman, “Portals of the Past” (1910 253
Fig. 50: Maynard Dixon, Sunset Magazine Cover (1906 257
Fig. 51: “Undaunted” (1915 259
Fig. 52: “A Return to Nature” (1906 261
Fig. 53: “True Grit” (1906 264
Fig. 54: “Refuge Camp” (1906 265
Fig. 55: “Fun Making” at the ‘House of Mirth’ (1906 266
Fig. 56: J.D. Givens, “Breadline at St. Mary’s Cathedral” (1906 272
Fig. 57: “Refugees Watching the Burning City” (1906 277
Fig. 58: “Safes Being Guarded” (1906 284
Fig. 59: “Photograph Showing the Terrible Effects” (ca. 1905 288
Fig. 60: “California Street […] Before the Fire” (1906 289
Fig. 61: Arnold Genthe, Untitled Photograph (1906 296
Fig. 62: “The Heart of Chinatown” (1906 301
Fig. 63: Arnold Genthe, “On the Ruins (April 1906 301
Fig. 64: “San Francisco Earthquake: Digging for Souvenirs” (1906 306
Fig. 65: “Looking East from Corner Ellis and Jones” (1906 309
Fig. 66: “Emergency Camp” (1906 312
Fig. 67: Detail from J.D. Givens, “Breadline at St. Mary’s” (1906 315
Fig. 68: Arnold Genthe, Photograph of Sacramento Street (1906 324
6. Conclusion 323
List of Figures 345
Fig. 1: “Clay St. from Knob Hill” (1906 47
Fig. 2: 16th-Century Woodcut of the 1570 Ferrara Earthquake 51
Fig. 3: 16th-Century Earthquake Illustration from the Cosmographia 59
Fig. 4: 18th-Century Copper Engraving “Lisabona 67
Fig. 5: “Lisbon Tragedy” (1755 67
Fig. 6: Detail from Copper Engraving “Lisbon, 1755” (ca.1755-1800 69
Fig. 7: “Lisbon, 1755: Before and After” (ca. 1770 70
Fig. 8: Le Bas, “The Opera House” (1757 73
Fig. 9: Detail from Pompeo Schiantarelli, “Monteleone, 1783” (1783 80
Fig. 10: New England Earthquake Woodcut Print (ca. 1744 92
Fig. 11: New England Earthquake Woodcut Print (ca. 1755 95
Fig. 12: “The Great Earthquake at New Madrid” (ca. 1851 101
Fig. 13: “Steamboat Navigating the Missouri” (ca. late 1850s-70s 103
Fig. 14: “Chicago in Flames” (1871 110
Fig. 15: “Swift Justice” (1872 112
Fig. 16: Drawing of the Masonic Temple in Chicago (1871 114
Fig. 17: “Northwest Corner Washington and LaSalle Sts.” (1871 114
Fig. 18: “The Earthquake” (1886 119
Fig. 19: “Charleston, South Carolina, Earthquake” (1886 123
Fig. 20: “Derailed Locomotive on Ten Mile Hill” (1886 123
Fig. 21: Logo of the San Francisco Museum and Hist. Society 128
Fig. 22: “Sixth Great Conflagration” (1851 148
Fig. 23: “Fire of May 4th, 1851” (ca. 1851-55 148
Fig. 24: Detail from “Fire of May 4th, 1851 150
Fig. 25: “View & Plan of the Burnt District” (1851 152
Fig. 26: Edward Jump, “Earth Quakey Times” (1865 172
Fig. 27: Detail from E. Jump, “Earth Quakey Times” (1865 174
Fig. 28: “The Great Earthquake in San Francisco [No. 1]” (1865 176
Fig. 29: Carleton Watkins, “Effects of the Earthquake” (1868 190
Fig. 30: Eadweard Muybridge, “Effect of Earthquake” (1868 194
Fig. 31: Earthquake Relief, Pompeii, Italy (1898 202
Fig. 32: Jack London, Untitled Photograph (1906 207
Fig. 33: “City Hall” (1906 216
Fig. 34: Sears, Roebuck, & Co. Advertisement (1908 219
Fig. 35: “The Burning Call Building” (1906 224
Works Cited 347